Darryl Sterdan's review: "Aaliyah comes into her own on these 15 immaculately produced cuts"

Latrice Davis' (AP) review: "may showcase the singer's talents, but it doesn't always do so to her advantage"

Bob Waliszewski reviews the pro-social and objectionable content of the album.

Bob Waliszewski reviews the pro-social and objectionable content of the album.

Bob Waliszewski reviews the pro-social and objectionable content of the album.

Aneta Tadeusiak and Chris Weller both give the album five stars.

Aneta Tadeusiak's review: "For a difficult half greatest hits and half new material album, 'I Care 4 U' doesn't do badly at all."